Can Paid Caregiver Support Unite People from Different Political Backgrounds?

Whether it is Family First or Love is Love, families are the cornerstone of any society

While in this political climate everyone seems to be going back to redesign (or undesign) mode, let's take a step back to underlying goals. What are we even trying to do here? Are there core goals we all share? Is it possible to build society more directly around those core shared goals? What is society's North Star?

At the heart of our collective experience are the moments of connection with our loved ones that truly matter: the quiet joy of watching a child laugh and grow, the comfort of being surrounded by those who understand and value you, and the satisfaction of engaging in work that ignites your passion. Whether expressed through the traditional refrain of “Family First” and “Protect Our Children” or through inclusive messages such as “Love is Love” and the dignity of every family, there exists a deep, shared yearning for connection, closeness, and support. These interpersonal experiences serve as a North Star, guiding us across political divides.

Families remain the cornerstone of every community. When families thrive, communities prosper. Research consistently demonstrates that stable family units correlate with lower rates of crime, poverty, and educational challenges.

So a key question becomes, if we are designing a world, what would a world built around enabling those connections look like? What are the things we need to enable, and what are the things we need to prevent?

In this context, paid caregiver support emerges as an example of a foundational policy capable of bridging political divides and uplifting society as a whole. Paid or other types of financial caregiver support, payment for the tremendous amount of work that goes into supporting families, supporting loved ones. Despite the universal appreciation for these interpersonal bonds, millions of Americans face the difficult task of balancing work, life, and the considerable responsibilities of caregiving without adequate support.

The Growing Need for Caregiving Support

Currently, more than 53 million Americans serve as unpaid caregivers, providing essential assistance to elderly relatives, individuals with disabilities, and those suffering from chronic illnesses. While the contributions of these caregivers are invaluable, they often come at a significant personal cost. According to the National Alliance for Caregiving and AARP, caregivers deliver an estimated 34 billion hours of care annually—a contribution valued at over $470 billion. Despite these remarkable contributions, the economic and emotional burdens experienced by caregivers remain largely unaddressed.

Demographic shifts further underscore the urgency of this issue. The U.S. Census Bureau projects that by 2034, adults aged 65 and older will outnumber children under 18, thereby intensifying the demand for long-term care. Although advances in healthcare have extended lifespans, they have also increased the prevalence of chronic conditions that require sustained, attentive care. This growing need accentuates the gap between the indispensable services provided by caregivers and the available support systems.

Providing paid caregiver support is not simply an economic adjustment; it is a recognition of the value of caregiving as genuine, indispensable work. Such support can alleviate the financial, physical, and emotional strains on caregivers while preserving the close, nurturing bonds that are the lifeblood of a thriving society.

A Policy Solution That Unites Us

Paid caregiver support offers a rare opportunity to find common ground among progressives, conservatives, and centrists. Although each political perspective emphasizes different aspects of the policy, the core idea remains universally appealing: strengthening families strengthens communities.

Progressive Perspective: Economic Justice and Income Support

For progressives, paid caregiver support represents an issue of economic justice. Recognizing caregiving as legitimate work is essential to addressing longstanding income and gender disparities. Key considerations include:

Valuing Unpaid Labor:Too often, caregiving—predominantly performed by women—remains an unrecognized and uncompensated contribution. Providing financial support acknowledges the economic value of this work, helping to redress gender imbalances and enhance family stability.
Reducing Financial Vulnerability:Many caregivers, especially those in low-income households, experience significant financial strain. Direct payments or paid leave provisions would provide a necessary safety net, enabling caregivers to remain in the workforce or pursue educational opportunities without sacrificing their familial responsibilities.

Conservative Perspective: Family Values and Fiscal Responsibility

From a conservative standpoint, paid caregiver support reinforces traditional family values while promoting sound fiscal management:

Strengthening the Family Unit: Conservatives have long maintained that strong families are the foundation of a healthy nation. By financially supporting those who care for elderly or disabled family members, paid caregiver support upholds the principle that care should primarily remain a family responsibility rather than becoming an overextended government obligation.
Cost-Effective Solutions: Home-based care, facilitated by caregiver stipends, is generally less expensive than institutional care. Initiatives like the VA’s caregiver stipend program not only provide critical support to families but also reduce long-term healthcare costs—an outcome that aligns with conservative fiscal priorities.
Empowering Local Solutions: Many conservatives favor state-led or private-sector approaches over broad federal mandates. Structuring support through mechanisms such as tax credits or dependent care deductions can afford states the flexibility to develop programs that meet local needs, fostering innovative and community-based solutions.

Healthcare and Workforce Participation (Centrist and Bipartisan Appeal)

Centrists and pragmatic policymakers appreciate the multi-faceted benefits of paid caregiver support:

Lowering Healthcare Costs:By enabling more effective home-based care, caregiver stipends can reduce hospital readmissions and decrease the overall burden on the healthcare system—a benefit that resonates with both fiscal conservatives and progressives.
Enhancing Workforce Participation:Financial support for caregivers reduces the likelihood that they will be forced to exit the workforce, thus maintaining economic productivity and ensuring that families continue to benefit from nurturing care.
Sustaining Interpersonal Bonds:Beyond the economic and operational benefits, paid caregiver support reinforces the fundamental human need for close, supportive relationships. When relieved of overwhelming financial and emotional stress, caregivers can focus on fostering the deep interpersonal connections that form the foundation of community well-being.

Broad Voter Support for Caregiver Initiatives

Public opinion strongly supports these types of initiatives. A 2021 AARP survey found that nearly 78% of Americans believe that family caregivers deserve financial assistance, and a 2022 Kaiser Family Foundation poll revealed that over 70% of voters back the expansion of home- and community-based services, including caregiver support. These statistics underscore that the call for supporting caregivers transcends partisan lines and resonates with a wide range of voters who see it as both a moral imperative and a practical solution to current societal challenges.

Emerging Policy Solutions Yet to Be Enacted Widely

While several existing programs demonstrate bipartisan success, there remain innovative policy solutions that have not yet been widely implemented but hold significant potential:

Universal Paid Caregiver Stipends:A federal program designed to provide direct, monthly payments to all eligible family caregivers on a sliding scale based on need. This universal approach could offer comprehensive support that adapts to varying caregiving demands.
Social Security Caregiver Credit Act:A proposal that would grant unpaid caregivers Social Security credits for their contributions, ensuring that their years of caregiving are reflected in future benefits. This measure would recognize caregiving as a form of labor that contributes to long-term economic security.
Expanded Dependent Care Tax Credit:An initiative to broaden the scope and eligibility of the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit to include caregiving for elderly relatives. By doing so, it would provide more robust financial relief to families balancing both childcare and eldercare responsibilities.
Caregiver Pension or Retirement Credit Scheme:Drawing inspiration from certain European models, this proposal would establish a caregiver pension plan that rewards long-term caregiving with retirement credits or benefits, thereby securing the financial future of those who dedicate their lives to family care.
Employer-Incentivized Caregiver Support Programs:Encouraging private-sector solutions through tax credits and incentives for businesses that offer comprehensive caregiver leave policies, flexible work arrangements, and support services. This strategy would promote robust caregiver benefits without necessitating extensive federal programs.

These emerging policy solutions illustrate the breadth of creative approaches available. Although they have not yet been widely enacted, they represent promising avenues for further research and bipartisan collaboration.

Real-World Examples of Bipartisan Wins

Across the nation, several programs demonstrate how paid caregiver support can unite diverse political viewpoints:

Veterans’ Caregiver Stipends: The Department of Veterans Affairs’ Program of Comprehensive Assistance for Family Caregivers is a prime example of bipartisan cooperation. This program extends stipends to caregivers of severely injured veterans, thereby honoring military service and ensuring that the families of veterans receive the support they need.
Tax Credit Initiatives: Legislative measures such as the Credit for Caring Act, which offers tax credits to family caregivers, illustrate how financial incentives can ease the economic burdens of caregiving without expanding federal entitlements. Such initiatives appeal to progressive ideals while aligning with conservative fiscal priorities.
State-Led Innovations: Many states have launched pilot programs that integrate tax incentives, Medicaid waivers, and direct support measures. These state-based approaches highlight the potential for tailored solutions that reflect local values and needs while advancing a unified commitment to family support.

Conclusion: A Unifying Investment in Our Future

Paid caregiver support is more than a policy proposal—it is an investment in the very foundation of our society. By providing direct financial assistance to those who perform essential caregiving work, we not only alleviate economic and emotional burdens but also reinforce the family bonds that nurture every community.

Viewed through the lenses of economic justice, traditional family values, or pragmatic workforce participation, the benefits of paid caregiver support are both clear and far-reaching. In an era marked by political division, this policy offers a rare point of common ground—a win for progressives seeking dignity and support, a win for conservatives advocating family-first solutions, and a win for centrists prioritizing effective, cost-efficient measures.

Ultimately, supporting paid caregiver programs—and exploring innovative policy solutions not yet widely enacted—is an investment in our collective North Star: the enduring importance of close, enriching connections that sustain families and, by extension, our nation.

By embracing a policy that honors our shared values and the everyday moments that define our lives, we can create a future in which every caregiver—and every family—receives the support they deserve.

References:

Felitti, V. J., Anda, R. F., Nordenberg, D., Williamson, D. F., Spitz, A. M., Edwards, V., & Marks, J. S. (1998). The relationship of adult health status to childhood abuse and household dysfunction. American Journal of Preventive Medicine.
Olds, D. L., Kitzman, H., Cole, R., & Robinson, J. (1997). Long-term effects of home visitation on maternal life course and child abuse and neglect: 15-year follow-up of a randomized trial. JAMA.
Schweinhart, L. J., Montie, J., Xiang, Z., Barnett, W. S., Belfield, C. R., & Nores, M. (2005). Lifetime Effects: The HighScope Perry Preschool Study Through Age 40.
Chetty, R., Hendren, N., & Katz, L. F. (2016). The Effects of Exposure to Better Neighborhoods on Children: New Evidence from the Moving to Opportunity Experiment. American Economic Review.
Putnam, R. D. (2000). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. Simon & Schuster.